Crew Cab vs Extended Cab: Which Pickup Truck Is Right for You?

When you're shopping for a crew cab, a full-size pickup truck configuration with four full-size doors and seating for up to six people, you're not just picking a truck—you're choosing how you live in it. The other main option, the extended cab, a mid-sized pickup with smaller rear doors and limited backseat space, often used for occasional passengers or gear, might seem like a budget-friendly alternative, but it’s not always the smarter pick. The difference isn’t just about door count or seat size—it’s about how you use your truck every day. If you haul kids, coworkers, or gear regularly, a crew cab gives you real room. If you mostly drive alone and only need extra space once in a while, an extended cab might do the trick.

Here’s the thing most dealers won’t tell you: extended cabs, also known as double cabs or access cabs depending on the brand often have rear seats that are barely usable for adults over 5’6". The legroom is tight, the entry is awkward, and the windows are small. Meanwhile, crew cabs, now standard on most full-size pickups like the Ford F-150, Ram 1500, and Chevrolet Silverado offer nearly the same interior comfort as a sedan. You can fit three adults in the back without feeling like you’re in a closet. And if you’ve ever tried to buckle a car seat in an extended cab, you know how much of a headache it is. Crew cabs make it easy. Plus, resale value? Crew cabs hold their price better—especially if you plan to sell in the next few years.

Price matters, sure. An extended cab can save you $2,000 to $5,000 upfront. But if you’re paying for gas, insurance, and maintenance anyway, why sacrifice comfort just to save a few grand? Think about your week: school runs, work trips, weekend hauls. Do you really want to squeeze into the back like a suitcase? Or would you rather have room to breathe? The crew cab isn’t just a bigger truck—it’s a better experience. And if you ever need to carry tools, gear, or even a dog without cramping your passengers, the extra space in the back seat isn’t a luxury—it’s a necessity.

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer, but the data doesn’t lie: over 70% of new pickup buyers today choose crew cabs. Why? Because once you’ve had the space, you don’t go back. The posts below cover everything from real-world comparisons of 2018 models to maintenance costs, resale trends, and even how to negotiate the best price based on cab style. Whether you’re looking at a Ford Ranger, a Toyota Tacoma, or a full-size Chevy, you’ll find the facts you need to make the right call—no sales pitch, no fluff, just what actually matters.